IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF NEW YORK COUNTY
Division of Internet Crime
and Copyright Infringement
Die Presse-verlagsgesellschaft M.b.h.
& Co Kg,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
Ubermorgen, Haas & Bernhard
Oeg, Hans Bernhard, Liz Haas, Lizvlx, EIS AG / Joker.com
Defendants.
)
)
) 02 CE 023
)
)
)
PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ORDER
This matter coming before the Court upon Plaintiffs' Emergency Motion for a
Temporary Restraining Order or Preliminary Injunction pursuant to Sections 5,
13 and 18 of the International Code of Civil Procedure (552, 131, 481 and 613),
seek declaratory judgment, injunctive and other relief against said Defendants
either jointly, severally or in the alternative, and upon Plaintiffs' verified
Complaint for Declaratory Judgment, Injunction and other relief filed against
Defendants Ubermorgen, Haas & Bernhard Oeg Hans Bernhard, Liz Haas, Lizvlx,
EIS AG / Joker.com, and the Court having reviewed and considered the allegations
in the verified complaint and exhibits thereto, as well as evidence presented
at the hearing on this Motion, and having heard and considered oral argument,
the Court finds as follows:
1. This
Court has subject matter jurisdiction over this action.
2. This
Court has personal jurisdiction over all of the parties in this action.
3. Venue
is proper in New York County.
4. Plaintiffs
Die Presse-verlagsgesellschaft M.b.h. & Co Kg, having standing to bring
this action.
5. Plaintiffs
have demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits and the proofs, once
submittedwould likely show that:
A. Defendants
Ubermorgen, Haas & Bernhard Oeg Hans Bernhard, Liz Haas, Lizvlx, EIS AG
/ Joker.com, and those acting in concert with them, have violated the laws of
the State of New York and of the United States by by reversing corporate signs
for their commercial purposes, including the main layout of a poster, the name
of a section of the newspaper and original picture material.
B. These
Defendants' continued use and operation of the Internet web site known as "ubermorgen.com",
a sub-site "ubermorgen.com/diepresse" and "ubermorgen.com/baby/"
as a forum for the purpose of encouraging, soliciting and allowing residents
of New York to and encouraging, soliciting and allowing individuals and corporations
to constitutes knowing and willful violations of the laws of the State of New
York and of the Unites States that will result in illegal activity if not prevented.
C. These
Defendants and all those acting in concert with them, including those New York
residents who have or will engage in or who have or will engage in actions as
described above, owe a duty to Plaintiffs and to all citizens of the State of
New York not to violate the laws of the State of New York and of the United
States.
D. These
Defendants and all those acting in concert with them, including those New York
residents who have or will engage in actions as described above, owe a duty
to Plaintiffs and to all citizens of the State of New York not to deprive them
of their rights and privileges under the Constitutions and laws of the State
of New York and of the United States to a save and truthworthy depiction of
reality on and in the internet.
E. These
Defendants and all those acting in concert with them, including those New York
residents who have or will engage in actions as described above or who have
or will deprive and defraud, and will continue to deprive and defraud if not
enjoined, the Plaintiffs and all citizens of the State of New York of their
rights and privileges under the Constitutions and laws of the State ofNew York
and of the United States to a save and truthworthy depiction of reality on and
in the internet.
F. That
anyone engaging in actions as described above or attempting to engage in actions
as described above, and anyone attempting to engage others in actions as described
above is in violation of the laws of the State of New York and of the United
States as enumerated herein.
6. Plaintiffs
possess certain and clearly demonstrated rights which need protection.
7. Plaintiffs
will suffer irreparable harm without protection of an injunction.
8. There
is no adequate remedy at law to compensate for Plaintiffs' injuries.
9. In the
absence of injunctive relief, the Plaintiffs would suffer greater harmwithout
an injunction than Defendants will suffer it is issued.
10. Defendants
have been notice of the Plaintiffs' Emergency Motion for a Temporary Restraining
Order.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that:
1. Defendants
and all those acting in concert with them are enjoined from:
A. Using
or operating any Internet web site that encourages or allows residents of New
York to access material as depicted on Defendants' web site.
B. Using,
operating, facilitating or accessing domain name "ubermorgen.com"
and to remove such web site from the Internet completely or, in the alternative,
to modify the Internet web site known as "ubermorgen.com" so as to
remove any illegal content.
C. Allowing
or continuing registration of the Internet domain name "ubermorgen.com"
or any other domain name offering substantially the same service as "ubermorgen.com".
D. Using
or operating in the State of New York any Internet web site by any name in any
manner that would violate prohibitions in the laws of the State of New York
and of the United States.
E. Accepting
from residents of the State of New York any registration or offer to use any
services provided by the web site known as "ubermorgen.com" and to
modify their web site to indicate that all registrations or offers to make use
of the web site by New York residents will be denied.
2. Defendants
and all those acting in concert with them and order them shall immediately disclose
to the proper authorities the names and addresses of every individual in New
York who has taken part or made use of the web site known as "ubermorgen.com"
and the names and addresses of every individual and/or entity that has paid
or has offered to pay for services of the web site known as "ubermorgen.com".
3. Defendants
shall within 15 days report to the Court on the measures they have taken to
implement this order.
4. The Court
shall retain jurisdiction over this matter.
Entered: _______________________________